Explore Bagel Me!’s menu, choose from popular bundles, or customize your catering order by contacting us. Order for delivery or pick-up.
The East Orange location offers catering from Bagel Me!, First Class Pizza and The Sugar Me Bakery. All other locations are limited to the Bagel Me! catering menu.
For more information on all of our Catering services, please give us a call or contact us.
Tray $37.95 serves up to 15 Two Trays $71.95 serves up to 30
Served with Cheese Garlic Stix
Great Garden Salad
House greens, cucumbers, avocado, broccoli, mushrooms, red bell peppers, green bell peppers, white onion, shredded carrots, mozzarella, tomato, ranch dressing.
Southwestern Chicken Salad
Chicken breast, avocado, black beans, kernel corns, Boarshead Vermont cheddar, Monterey Jack, white onion, tomato, fresh cilantro, tortilla strips, spicy ranch dressing.
BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad
Chicken breast, black beans, fresh cilantro, kernel corn, onion, tomato, Boarshead Vermont cheddar, Monterey Jack, tortilla strips, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce.
Chicken Artichoke Salad
Chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, artichokes, grape tomato, house greens, Balsamic Vinaigrette.
Crisp Romaine, parmesan, grape tomatoes, Caesar dressing.
Tray $31.95 Two Trays $61.95
Fresh Fruit Tray
One Tray $33.95 serves up to 15
Two Trays $61.95 serves up to 30
The Sugar Me Bakery
Dessert Bar Platter $49.95
An assortment of 36 petite Lemon Bars, Raspberry Almond Bars, Triple Chocolate Walnut Brownies.
Pecan Bars and Pumpkin Bars (seasonal)
Jumbo Buttercream Cupcakes
everyday flavors $48.00 per dozen
specialty flavors $50.10 per dozen
Standard and Mini Sizes Available
Round or Sheet Cakes
15% discount when ordered with catering
48 hour notice
(extra design may require more than 48 hours)
Fresh Baked Cookies $14.45 per dozen
Chocolate Chip Walnut, Snickerdoodle, M&M Chocolate Chip, M&M Snickerdoodle
Our Famous Pumpkin Cookies with cinnamon icing (seasonal)