Check out the Bagel Me! East Orange menu for delivery, takeout or dine-in. Menus vary by location so be sure to check out the menu from the location you plan to order from.
At this location you can add First Class Pizza and The Sugar Me Bakery to your order. All three concepts are located at this store.
Note: This is the menu for East Orange which is different from the Orange Circle location. The Orange Circle menu can be found here.
Bagel Selections
sourdough, garlic, onion, cheese, cheese onion, cheese jalapeño, cheese everything, sesame seed, everything, salt, poppyseed, glazer, whole wheat glazer, cinnamon raisin, energy bar, multigrain, plain, jalapeño, very berry, blueberry, chocolate chip, pumpkin (seasonal)
Regular Varieties
$2.19 each
Cheese Varieties & Energy Bars
$2.29 each
$19.95 per dozen; $9.95 per 1/2 dozen
Bagel Bundle
$32.95 – 18 bagels and two 8oz tubs of plain cheese
Small Bagel Bundle
$13.95 – 6 bagels and one 8oz tub of plain cream cheese
Cream Cheese Flavors
plain, lite, veggie, strawberry, jalapeno onion, jalapeno cheddar, walnut raisin,
sun-dried tomato, lox spread, pumpkin (seasonal)
Lox & Cream Cheese $10.45
served with bagel chips and baked apples
Lox, Red Onion, Tomato & Cream Cheese $11.45
served with bagel chips and baked apples
Bagel Toppings
Butter .80
Jam .80
Plain or Lite Cream Cheese $2.25
Lox Spread $3.10
Specialty Cream Cheese $2.55
Crunchy Peanut Butter $2.35
Cinnamon Toasted $2.35
your choice of bagel with butter, cinnamon sugar toasted
Omelets
Three fresh eggs, cottage fries, 1/2 toasted egg bagel with butter.
Served until 11am (1pm Saturday/Sunday)
Cheese Omelet $10.99
Boarshead Cheddar, Monterey Jack cheese with a touch of green onion
Fresh Veggie Omelet $12.25
Yellow squash, zucchini, fresh mushrooms, green bell pepper, tomato, caramelized onion, cheddar and Monterey cheeses
Bacon, Tomato, Avocado (BTA) Omelet $12.99
Hardwood Smoked Bacon, fresh avocado, fresh tomato, Boarshead Cheddar, Monterey Jack cheeses
Denver Omelet $12.55
Premium ham, onion, green bell pepper, Boarshead Cheddar, Monterey Jack cheeses
Eggs
Three eggs, cottage fries, 1/2 egg bagel toasted with butter $8.25
add 3 sausage or bacon $2.25
Breakfast Egg Melts
$10.95
egg bagel, served with cinnamon baked apples
Egg, Cheddar, Bacon
Egg, Cheddar, Sausage
Egg, Cheddar, Ham
Chipotle Bacon Egg Melt
Hardwood smoked bacon, Boarshead cheddar, chipotle sauce
Egg, Jack, Avocado & Tomato
Egg, Cheddar & Veggie
mushrooms, zucchini, yellow squash, bell peppers, broccoli, onion
Specialty Breakfast
served until 11am (12pm Saturdays/Sundays)
Scrambles $8.75
3 eggs, cottage fries, slice of egg bagel toasted with butter
add cheese $1.00, add 3 sausages or bacon $2.50
Bagel Me! French Toast $8.25
Scrumptious slices of egg bagel in a sweet cinnamon egg dip.
add side of three sausage or Hardwood smoked bacon $2.50
Steel Cut Oatmeal $4.35
Served with raisins and brown sugar.
Great with our cinnamon baked apples .50
Bagel Sandwiches
Served with bagel chips and cinnamon baked apples. Substitute French Fries $2.25
add cheese .75: Boarshead Cheddar, Monterey Jack, Boarshead Provolone, Pepper Jack, Swiss
Turkey Breast $10.95
egg bagel, 97% fat free turkey, lettuce, tomato, Dijon sauce
Turkey, Bacon, Avocado $13.95
egg bagel, 97% fat free turkey, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, Dijon sauce
Turkey, Bacon, Swiss $11.45
egg bagel, 97% fat free turkey, bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, Dijon sauce
Cranberry Turkey $11.25
egg bagel, 97% fat free turkey, cranberry, cream cheese, lettuce
White Albacore Tuna $10.75
onion bagel, white albacore tuna, lettuce, tomato
Premium Ham $10.95
egg bagel, ham, lettuce, tomato, super sauce
Western Chicken $11.95
egg bagel, chicken breast, jack cheese, fresh grilled mushrooms, caramelized onions, Dijon sauce
Chicken, Bacon, Avocado $13.95
egg bagel, chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, Dijon sauce
BLT $11.45
add avocado $2.25
egg bagel, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise
Vegetarian $11.45
multigrain bagel, cucumber, avocado, swiss cheese, red bell pepper, lettuce, tomato, white onion, mayonnaise
Bagel Melts
Open face bagel, with cinnamon baked apples and bagel chips.
Substitute French Fries $2.25, Add Avocado $2.25
Chipotle Bacon Melt $12.25
jalapeno bagel, grilled onions, Monterey jack, tomato
Turkey Melt $11.25
egg bagel, turkey breast, swiss cheese, tomato
Tuna Melt $11.75
onion bagel, white Albacore tuna, Boarshead cheddar, tomato
Ham Melt $11.25
egg bagel, ham, Boarshead cheddar, tomato
Veggie Melt $11.55
multigrain bagel, fresh mushrooms, yellow squash, cauliflower, zucchini, broccoli, bell peppers, grilled onions, Boarshead cheddar, tomato
Hamburgers
Going the extra mile to make a better burger. Our hamburger buns are made in house. We use only hand crafted USDA Choice hamburger, fresh pickles, crisp lettuce with no preservatives and tomato. Our traditional super sauce is made from scratch.
Served with baked apples and bagel chips. Substitute French Fries $2.25
add cheese .65 Boarshead Cheddar, Monterey Jack, Boarshead Pepper Jack, Swiss, Provolone, Mozzarella, Add Avocado $2.25
Traditional Hamburger $10.95
add cheese .75c
Lettuce, tomato, fresh pickle, super sauce
Bacon Avocado Cheeseburger $14.75
Hardwood smoked bacon, avocado, Boarshead Cheddar, lettuce, tomato, fresh pickles, super sauce
BBQ Cheeseburger $11.95
Boarshead cheddar, Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce, onion ring, tomato
Chipotle Bacon Cheeseburger $13.95
Gilled onions, tomato, chipotle sauce
Mushroom & Swiss Burger $12.95
Boarshead swiss, sautéed mushrooms, pickles, lettuce, tomato & super sauce
Frisco Burger $14.95
1/2 lb USDA Choice hamburger on grill toasted parmesan sourdough, fresh pickles, tomato, lettuce, super sauce
Specialty Sandwiches
Served after 11am
Served with baked apples and bagel chips. Substitute fries $1.95
Sourdough Bread Sandwiches
Jalapeno Turkey $14.95
97% fat free turkey, avocado, bacon, jalapenos, Boarshead pepperjack, tomato, greens on parmesan grilled sourdough
Club Sandwich $14.95
Lean turkey breast, bacon, avocado, Boarshead provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo, toasted
Grilled Parmesan Sourdough Sandwiches
Super BLT $12.95
loads of Hardwood smoked bacon, ripe tomatoes, lettuce, mayonnaise
Super Grilled Cheese $10.95
Boarshead cheddar, Tillamook pepper jack, avocado, tomato, fresh ground pepper
Grilled Cheese $7.95
Boarshead cheddar, Monterey Jack cheeses
Artisan Roll Sandwiches 10″
Meatball Sandwich $12.99
Made from scratch marinara, shredded mozzarella, parmesan. Served with fries
Full Italian Sandwich $12.99
Boarshead salami, Capicola, ham, provolone, red onion, fresh pickle, greens tomato
Turkey Breast $11.99
97% fat free turkey, tomato, red onion, provolone, greens, pepperoncinis, Italian Dressing
Veggie $12.99
Avocado, green & red bell peppers, red onion, tomato, greens, pepperoncinis, provolone, Italian Dressing
Squaw Bread Sandwiches
Squaw Bread Veggie $9.75
add tuna $1.85
avocado, cucumber, pickle, swiss, onion, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise
Salads
Served after 11am daily.
Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Italian, Spicy Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, BBQ Ranch.
Add White Albacore Tuna $2.25
Great Garden Salad
$8.75 / $11.25
chopped house greens, cucumbers, onion, mozzarella, tomato, avocado, broccoli, mushrooms, red & green bell peppers.
Ranch dressing
Southwestern Chicken Salad
$9.55 / $13.75
seasoned breast of chicken, avocado, black beans, kernel corn, onion, tomato, Boarshead cheddar, Monterey jack, fresh cilantro, tortilla strips and spicy ranch dressing.
Chopped Italian Salad
$9.55 / $13.75
chopped house greens, pepperoni, salami, artichokes, olives, provolone cheese, tomato, pepperoncini, red onion, red & green bell peppers, balsamic vinaigrette.
Chicken Artichoke
$9.55 / $13.75
breast of chicken, fresh mozzarella, artichokes, grape tomato, fresh basil, house mixed greens, balsamic vinaigrette.
BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad
$9.55 / $13.75
breast of chicken, black beans, fresh cilantro, kernel corn, onion, tomato, Boarshead cheddar, Monterey Jack, corn chips, BBQ ranch dressing.
Side Salad
$5.25
house mixed greens, tomato, cucumbers, broccoli, red onions, mozzarella.
Italian dressing.
Appetizers
Cheese Fries
$4.35 / $6.25
Onion Rings
$5.95
Cottage Fries
$4.45 / $6.95
French Fries
$3.50 / $4.85
Chicken Tenders & Fries
$12.45
Irish Nachos
French fries, bacon bits, green onion, cheddar & jack cheeses
$8.45
Pasta
Served after 11am
Served with Garlic Bread
Spaghetti Marinara $8.95
Spaghetti & Meatballs $10.35
Fettucini Alfredo $9.95
Chicken & Broccoli Fettucini $11.45
Chicken & Mushroom Fettucini $11.45
Beverages, Iced, Blended & Other Drinks
Coffee
16oz $2.59 / 20oz $2.79
Cold Brew Coffee
16oz $3.45 / 24oz $4.95
Blended Mocha or Vanilla
topped with whipped cream
16oz $4.95 / 20oz $5.95
Hot Tea
$2.45
Hot Cocoa
topped with whipped cream
16oz $3.45
Super “C” OJ
16oz $5.25 / 24oz $6.25
Fresh Squeezed OJ
16oz $3.95 / 24oz $5.55
Soft Drinks/Iced Tea
24oz $2.79 / 32oz $3.25
Smoothies
16oz $5.45 / 24oz $7.89
Watermelon Shooter
watermelon juice, strawberries, non-fat frozen yogurt
Razzle Dazzle
raspberry juice, strawberries, banana, orange sherbet
Banaberry
apple juice, blueberries, banana, non-fat frozen yogurt, raspberry sherbet
Strawberry Splash
apple juice, strawberries, banana, non-fat frozen yogurt
Raspberry Royale
raspberry juice, raspberries, banana, non-fat frozen yogurt
Cranberry Chill
cranberry juice, raspberries, blueberries, raspberry sherbet, non-fat frozen yogurt
Razzleberry
raspberry juice, boysenberries, blueberries, non-fat frozen yogurt
Morning Glory
peach juice, peaches, banana, honey, non-fat frozen yogurt
Passion Mango
peach fruit juice, mango juice, strawberries, peaches, banana, pineapple sherbet
Maui
pineapple juice, strawberries, banana, coconut, honey
Pineapple Pleasure
pineapple juice, banana, non-fat frozen yogurt and non-fat plain yogurt
Orange Sunrise
fresh orange juice, strawberries, banana, non-fat frozen yogurt
Peachy Keen
peach juice, peaches, banana, non-fat frozen yogurt
Orange Crush
fresh orange juice, strawberries, blueberries, pineapple sherbet
Citrus Blend
fresh orange juice, pineapple juice, strawberries, banana, orange sherbet
Marathon
fresh orange juice, strawberries, banana, protein
Raspberry Twist
pineapple juice, raspberry juice, raspberries, peaches, orange sherbet, non-fat frozen yogurt
Passionate Mango
peach fruit juice, mango juice, strawberries, peaches, orange sherbet
Peach Peach
fresh peach juice, peaches, banana, orange sherbet
Shakes
16oz $5.45 / 24oz $7.89
Vanilla or Chocolate Shake
made with real ice cream and topped with fresh whipped cream
Peanut Parade Shake
non-fat milk, banana, peanut butter, non-fat frozen yogurt
Dessert
$4.95
Triple Chocolate Brownies with nuts
three kinds of chocolate, highly recommended.
Lemon Bars
“Most Popular”
Raspberry Almond Bars
Pecan Bars
Triple Chocolate Brownies with NO nuts
Jumbo Rice Krispies
Jumbo Cupcakes
real buttercream
Chocolate, vanilla, birthday cake, red velvet
Call for other flavors